For those of us living in Scotland, the current
political shenanigans in London are more than a
little puzzling. The Conservatives, under David
Cameron, won the UK election with the largest number
of seats. Surely, therefore, they should have taken
over the reigns of power by now?
Instead, Gordon Brown is still at No 10, while the
Conservatives discuss becoming a happy couple with
the Lib Dems, having previously torn lumps out of
their policies right up to Election Day on Thursday.
This whole paranoia about hung parliaments has been
extraordinary for us to watch.
It seems quite clear that many in the electorate
wanted a hung parliament. They wanted the election
winner to be in a position where they:
- had to moderate their more extreme
policies
- and had to work to create a consensus to get
their legislation passed.
That’s precisely the situation the Scottish
Parliament has been in since the last election here.
The SNP have most seats (just as the Conservatives do
across the UK), but they do not have an overall
majority.
Alex Salmond and his SNP cabinet have therefore had
to build a consensus issue-by-issue to progress their
business.
- Has it brought the Scottish parliament to its
knees? Not at all.
- Has it stagnated parliamentary business?
No.
- Has it meant the SNP has had its own way in the
parilament? No.
- Has it meant the SNP hqas had to moderate some
of its policies? Yes.
Against that background it is baffling why the
Conservatives apparently have to create an overall
majority by doing a deal with their arch-enemies.
Even more baffling that some commentators seem to
suggest that a “rainbow” coalition of the minorities
(Labour, Liberal and others) might be the answer.
Sure, that might be a more popular solution in
Scotland, where the Conservatives would always be
challenged over their right to govern for Scotland
when they could only muster enough Scottish support
for one MP on Thursday.
But we want a decisive team in charge of the country.
So, would the winners of the election please stop
dithering and get on with the job of government....
even if it is with a minority.
- Footnote: Yes, I am aware that – despite the
presidential-style debates – we do not elect a
Prime Minister. We elect a government, who then
elect a Prime Minister. But the outcome is,
usually, very much the same.
Tags: politics, blogs